|

What do we wish to achieve by teaching about the
Holocaust? There is no question that one of our primary
goals should be to provide students with a full and
extensive knowledge of the historical facts. However,
the problem in treating the Holocaust merely as history
is that history can dissolve into irrelevance. Our
intention should be that as a result of learning about
the Holocaust, our students emerge with a greater
understanding of the limits of human perfectibility
and potential. Through such an understanding they
may strive for self-improvement.
Teachers of Jewish students should bear in mind Emil
Fackenheim's directive to all Jews to "listen
to the voice of Auschwitz". An important goal
should be to have Jewish students consider their own
responsibilities as Jews in the light of Fackenheim's
assertion that Jews have a sacred obligation to survive
and are forbidden to hand Hitler a posthumous victory
by despairing of or abandoning Judaism.

In order for (Jewish or non-Jewish) students to understand
why Nazism took root so easily in Germany, it needs
to be presented as the culmination of centuries of
antisemitism in Europe generally and in Germany in
particular. (See Antisemitism
and Nazi Antisemitism.)
The terminology of the Holocaust is complex and requires
some attention. The scope and numbers of people involved
are difficult to grasp and often benefit from graphic
representations and/or comparisons to familiar numbers
and reduction to individual and personal proportions.
When dealing with the issues of guilt and responsibility
for the Holocaust, the scope of responsibility needs
to be widened. Teaching about the Holocaust should
not become simply a means of condemning the Nazis,
for in this approach some key lessons will be lost.
Students need to be taught about the world's overwhelming
silence in the face of Nazi barbarism and to examine
concepts including the basic responsibility of all
human beings for each others' welfare. (For all the
topics mentioned here, see Lesson
Ideas.)
The Holocaust can be studied in many different contexts:
ghettos, death camps, forests, places of hiding and
so on. Given the time constraints that most teachers
must consider, many decide to focus on the ghetto
situation. This is because it represents Jewish experience
in microcosm, providing the best insight into the
continuum of events, including the richness of Jewish
cultural life before the Holocaust.
Another important methodological consideration which
needs to be kept in mind is the need to avoid presenting
the Holocaust as nothing more than a horror story.
The intention should not be to deliberately shock
or inspire a ghoulish fascination. Some students,
especially some of those younger than about 15, revel
in the violent aspects of history and tend to glorify
violence and those who enact it. Focusing on the horrors
of the Holocaust is most undesirable for this general
reason, but also in the sense that it reduces those
people who suffered them to the status of 'victims',
further depersonalising them, as was the intention
of their Nazi oppressors and murderers.
When teachers and students are faced with the visual
and literary evidence of the Holocaust they may be
intimidated, unsettled and even frightened. It is
only by carefully confronting the facts that people
can come to terms with the key moral and historical
issues. Whether as a case study or as an integral
part of European and world history, the basic messages
remain to be learnt: humanity's capacity for inhumanity,
repression, racism and genocide. The ultimate question
for both teachers and students is: 'How we can ensure
that such barbarism does not happen again?'
|