|

Lynda Ben-Menashe,
b. 1964, Sydney, Australia.
"I
was born in Australia in 1964 and have lived here
almost all of my life. I think my experiences are
quite typical of those of many Australian Jews of
my generation. I would never call Australia an antisemitic
country; far from it, I feel that it is one of the
most peaceful and ethnically tolerant societies in
the world. But that is not to say that antisemitism
does not exist here.
I grew up in what is usually described as a very
affluent suburb on Sydney's North Shore and attended
only public schools. The ethnic mix of these schools
was mainly white, Anglo-Saxon and Protestant, but
there were some Southern Europeans, Hong Kong Chinese
and Jews; Jews made up about 20% of the school population.
The first experience of antisemitism I had was in
Year 1 (1970), when at Christmas time I asked the
teacher if our class might learn some Chanukah songs
in addition to the obligatory Christmas carols. (Chanukah
is a Jewish festival of freedom which occurs around
Christmas time most years.) The teacher agreed, but
apparently some of the parents did not and there was
a huge outcry that their Christian children should
not be exposed to any 'foreign' culture.
When I was about 8 I stopped going to the local Brownie
Guides. It had been Mothers' Day and we were making
presents for our mothers which were a bar of soap
with pins stuck in it in the shape of a cross. I had
asked if I could stick my pins in the shape of a Star
of David and a deathly silence had fallen. 'No,' I
was told, 'You can only make a cross.' After this
incident, a classmate informed me that she was no
longer allowed to be my friend. Her parents had told
her that 'all Jews have black hearts.' If you wonder
how I can remember the words so clearly, just imagine
the impression they would have made on a child of
that age.
In my first term at High School, Year 7, 1976 one
day a boy just attacked me, physically, with an umbrella,
screaming that I was a Jew. I was the youngest and
smallest student in the year; I'd never seen this
boy before, a big fat boy who had swastikas painted
on his bags and books. There was some response from
the school, I don't remember what, but I do remember
that all the Jewish boys in our year beat him up and
that shut him up for a few years.
I was elected School Captain in Year 12, and coincidentally
the boy captain was Jewish too. So surely that was
a sign that there was no antisemitism. But the entire
year, I don't think one week went by when the box
for letters to the prefects from other students didn't
contain one or more antisemitic letters. 'Kill the
Jews' 'We hate you all' Scrawled drawings of the boy
captain and I with nooses around our necks. And on
the day our HSC (matriculation exams) began, we arrived
at school to find it covered with horrible graffiti,
swastikas, 'Hitler didn't kill enough'.
It must sound strange, but what I recall is a really
wonderful school life with lots of friends, only two
or three of them Jewish. But I heard the message loud
and clear and it was: 'You are not one of us, no matter
how much a part of this society you think you are.'
I think I just accepted that that was how things were,
and it only made my resolve in my own identity stronger.
At university I joined and became active in the Union
of Jewish Students. In 1982 I was part of a group
who toured our state, debating 'anti-Zionist' groups
about Israel's invasion of Lebanon. Many of us Jewish
students were either opposed to or very ambivalent
about that war, but the antisemitism of the campus
presses had prompted us to defend Israel in principle.
Seeing the image of then-Israeli Prime Minister Menachem
Begin depicted in SS uniform leaning over a globe,
with blood dripping from his hands was something we
just could not ignore. We felt we couldn't let plain,
simple, ugly antisemitism be disguised as 'anti-Zionism';
especially not in such vicious terms, with that blatant
depiction of Begin, a Jewish Holocaust survivor, as
a Nazi.
I knew I could only marry someone Jewish, not only
because I wanted to, but also because I felt sure
no non-Jewish man would be interested in me. When
non-Jewish boys from Uni asked me out I was always
shocked. I would go, but feeling a fraud, as if they
didn't realise that they had made a terrible mistake;
they couldn't possibly have known I was Jewish or
they wouldn't have asked me.
Anyway, I married: an Israeli Jew, and we have lived
both in Israel and here in Australia. And there I
feel at home but alien in some ways, and here I do
as well. In Israel I am referred to as an 'Anglo-Saxon'!
How bizarre. And our children speak Hebrew and are
getting a far better formal Jewish education than
I had. But I wonder, will their Jewish identities
be as strong as mine is if they don't experience the
antisemitism I did? There's the real irony."
|